The Retentionist. Turning one-time buyers into regulars

The retention journal

Turning one‑time buyers into regulars

The Retentionist is a working journal on customer retention in ecommerce. We read the platform benchmarks, take the flows apart and write down what actually brings buyers back: email and SMS, loyalty, win-back and the numbers behind repeat purchases.

  • 30% store can be
  • 12.39% click rate but
  • 3.33% placed order rate
Warm boutique shop counter where a returning customer is being welcomed
Retention starts at the counter: the second visit is the one that counts.

Latest from the journal

Follow via RSS →
Benchmarks

Email Frequency: How Many Sends the Data Supports

Merchants keep asking for a magic number of emails per week, but the measured data settles a narrower question: what a send is worth, what happens above 5,000 messages a day, and why the answer is about deliverability rules and return math rather than a calendar.

Email Sms

Segmentation 101 for Stores: Five Segments That Pay First

Merchants searching for email segmentation examples usually want a list of clever audience names, but the thing that actually determines whether segmentation pays off is whether the storefront and the underlying customer data can support it at all, which is a code and API question, not a naming question.

Email Sms

Preference Centers: The Unsubscribe Rate Antidote

Merchants keep assuming their theme has a built-in preference center setting somewhere, and the honest answer is that the two most common Shopify themes carry no such section at all, which is the thing this article settles.

Email Sms

Loyalty Points Math: What a Point Should Cost You

Merchants asking what a loyalty point should cost usually reach for an industry rule of thumb, but the honest answer is that the question cannot be settled with a loyalty number at all because no dataset here measures loyalty points, so what actually settles is which platform tier and theme foundation you build the program on.

Email Sms

Deliverability 2026: The Gmail and Yahoo Rules for Stores

The usual answer treats deliverability as a theme setting you can toggle, but the actual requirements live in sender authentication rules from Google, not in any Shopify theme's code, and confusing the two wastes time a store owner does not have.

A smartphone lying on linen showing an email notification beside a terracotta ceramic bowl and dried flowers
Teardown

Browse Abandonment Email Examples: What Good Ones Do

Eleven real browse abandonment emails from a documented public roundup, read for patterns instead of pretty screenshots. The good ones share four moves, and almost none of them lead with a discount.

30% The gap is structural, not a skill difference. Banks and insurers retain through contracts and switching costs; a store re-earns every single order. A 30% store can be healthier than a 75% telecom.
12.39% Omnisend's 2026 dataset of 321 million texts puts campaign SMS at a 12.39% click rate but only 0.12% conversion and $0.15 revenue per message, while automated SMS converts at 0.77% and returns $0.74 per send.
3.33% Klaviyo's benchmark of 143K+ cart flows shows the average brand at a 3.33% placed order rate and $3.65 revenue per recipient, while the top 10% reach 7.69% and $28.89. The practices below are the visible differences between those two groups.